Walt Disney Animation Studios Review: Alice In Wonderland

Walt Disney Animation Studios 13th feature film


My opinion right after watching movie

My opinion right after watching the film is that I feel like it is like a package film, and when a film is not a package film and SEEMS like one, that is an issue. There is no plot until the 50 minute mark and everything before that is an episodic segment. This film is not good storytelling.


So Walt Disney had a long history with the source material. His first official work was a bunch of Alice shorts that he used as a part of his portfolio from the 1920s. In 1932, he was thinking about making an animated/live action hybrid film of Alice starring Mary Pickford, and he got the rights for it, but another live action Alice came out, and the studio eventually went to work on Snow White instead.

They revamped the project again after Snow White was released, and the storyboards were complete, but he did not like it. That along with the war and the productions of Pinocchio, Bambi and Fantasia got him to shelve the project again. In 1946, the production for the film as we know it started, and the studio did not want it to be too close to the source material. A lot of the unused material for this film went into Peter Pan.


The movie starts with Alice (Kathryn Beaumont) getting read a history book by her sister (Heather Angel), and she is extremely bored and starts to daydream. Her sister scolds her for daydreaming, and continues on reading her book. Alice sneaks off from the tree they were at and sings the song In a World of My Own, which establishes her curiosity and boredom of her world. She sees a rabbit (Bill Thompson) running about being late, and follows it, causing her to fall in a rabbit hole in a tree.

Okay, who in your damn mind gave you the right to walk out of your sister like that? And WHY would you go in a rabbit hole when you are supposed to be learning from your sister. That would not fly by with my siblings.

So she finally reaches down the rabbit hole, which is an excuse for the animators to show off their animation, and she sees the rabbit go through a door, but she can not get in. A bottle that says “Drink Me” pops off and she drinks it, shrinking. She starts crying and the door (Joseph Kearns) tells her to eat the cookie to make her grow to get the key. After all of that goes on, she shrinks into the bottle, and makes it through the door.

Now HERE is when the plot disappears and it turns into a package film. We have a bunch of dumb pointless segments that add ABSOLUTELY NOTHING. If it WAS a package film, then I would be giving props, but it is a FULL FEATURE FILM. What the hell is this? This is such bad storytelling. You could literally switch these around, and no difference would be made. And he had different directors for each segment so they can have each have a different flavour. BIG mistake.

So she goes to the Rabbit’s house, and grows to a giant in his house. He still continues to go off and run to go somewhere. She licks a piece of food and shrinks. We than suffer from a few more segments before we get to the Merry Unbirthday Tea Party. The Mad Hatter (Ed Wynn), March Hare (Jerry Colonna), and the Dormouse (Jimmy MacDonald) are acting like they are high off of LSD, and the rabbit finally show sup to ultimately get kicked out. Alice gets tired of the foolishness and runs off to find her way home.

So she sings Very Good Advice, and it is actually kind of a sad moment. Oh, and the plot returns around here.

So the Cheshire Cat  (Sterling Holloway) reappears, and gives her the shortcut to make it home by going to the Queen of Hearts (Verna Felton).  She goes to the castle, and after helping the cards paints the roses red, the Queen snaps and finds Alice. She asks Alice to participate in a golf like sport, and this leads to a funny yet ridiculous scene of the animal balls and the cards trying to make Alice lose and the Queen win.

So Alice somehow ends up in court and is given the verdict before the trial even begins. Alice loses it and snaps at the Queen. This causes the Queen to demand her head get cut off, and Alice runs from Wonderland, which ends up her waking up. She is woken up by the tree, by herself (she was not by herself and was not laying on the floor when she was at the tree in the beginning). The film ends with her, her sister and Dinah going home for tea.

It is like they did not know if they wanted to make a package film or a feature film. That should NEVER be an issue when it comes to making a movie. Alice does eventually learn her lesson, and I like how they made it all happen in her dreams, but if there was an ACTUAL PLOT, it would have been so much better. Not only does it barely have story, but the execution is awful, it feels like I am supposed to be on a drug trip (and I do not do drugs), and is just unpleasant to me.


There are so many characters that are in this film for 2-5 minutes, and never seen again. Even the so called supporting cast are barely in the film. Alice is a good enough character though.

Alice is curious, optimistic, and a smart girl. She learns that not everything can be nonsense…… that is all I have for her.
He is very mysterious and cool.
All she does is scream. It is like she is a little baby.
Ugh, I do not know why he is seen as a main character when he appears less than 10 minutes of the film. He is….. noisy, but fun to watch I guess.


The animation in this film is WONDERFUL. Mary Blair (who worked on Cinderella) made amazing, detailed and stylized backgrounds. The coloring is very vibrant and stand out. I could not find any inconsistencies when it came to the animation. The way they handled transformations (like Alice’s height varying) are so cool to watch. The animation is the thing that stands out the most about the film.


The music is…..decent. Well, it is good, but there are too many songs to remember them, and they are not long shorts. Many of them very from seconds long to less than 2 minutes. These songs are very fast paced (which somewhat works for the film), but it does kind of make things seem crazier. Decent is the only word I can use for it. There was no need for all of these short songs.

Reception at Release

When the film was released on  July 26, 1951, it did not do well. It only made $2.4 million out of its $3 million budget, and it received mixed reviews. Many fans of the book did not like how it was Americanized, while critics thought it was a hot ass mess in writing. He was disappointed in the reception, and it was never rereleased in theaters during his lifetime. Many predict that if Cinderella was not such a huge success the previous year, Alice would have sunk the studio and they would have closed down; not making it through the 50s.

Reception Today

It became popular in the early 70s due to the hippie age and the drug culture (go figure), after Disney has passed away. It has been released many times since then, and has been deemed as a classic. It has a 2010 live action film called Alice in Wonderland, which went on to make over a billion dollars.

Final Score

Story: 3.5/10

Characters: 4.5/10

Animation: 8.5/10

Music: 6.5/10=

23/40 =58%

Next Time…

Review: March 17th, 2014

13 thoughts on “Walt Disney Animation Studios Review: Alice In Wonderland

  1. Well as you know, I love this movie! And you really can’t blame them for making this movie as just a series of episodes that Alice goes through because that’s what the original books by Lewis Carroll are like. There really is no plot in them, rather it’s just one event followed by another followed by another. It’s supposed to “seem like a package film”.

    Alice is probably my favorite Disney female character.

    Oh, great job sticking up to your beliefs of sibling love and respect!

    1. Yes, In my family, sibling and family respect is very important, and if you do not show it, you will get cursed out.

      I know the books never had a plot, but they could have at least tried to give it a story. Disney was never shy of changing the source material to add more story. To each their own, I see certain things as to why you like it.

  2. I remember reading somewhere how Walt Disney said “Alice in Wonderland” ultimately lacked heart in the story that he wanted. Personally, I loved the movie as a child, but in comparison to other versions and other Disney films, it’s a tough seller.

    1. Yes, Disney did say that after the movie was released I believe, and he is so correct, This film is definitely one that you either love, or dislike.

  3. I think of this film like a road trip movie, like Doug Walker does; you see one strange thing, have an encounter with it, and move on to the next strange thing. And I, like Animation Commendation, consider it one of my favorite films in the canon. I like the humor, the animation, the color palette, and Alice is a very nice lead.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s